Guide

CPR 35.7: single joint expert or party appointed expert

Updated

This decision changes the fee more than any other single choice in an expert instruction, and it also changes what you are entitled to expect from the expert.

Get forensic accounting quotes Two minutes to set out the instruction; forensic accountants respond directly with their fee basis and a stage estimate.

What CPR 35.7 and rule 35.8 provide

CPR 35.7(1): where two or more parties wish to submit expert evidence on a particular issue, the court may direct that a single joint expert gives it. Rule 35.7(2) lets the court select the expert if the parties cannot agree. Under rule 35.8 any relevant party may give instructions, but must at the same time copy the other relevant parties.

On fees, the court may:

  • give directions about payment of the expert's fees and expenses;
  • limit the amount payable before the expert is instructed;
  • direct that some or all of the parties pay that amount into court.

Unless the court otherwise directs, the relevant parties are jointly and severally liable for the fees and expenses (justice.gov.uk).

The comparison

Single joint expert and party appointed expert compared
PointSingle joint expertParty appointed expert
Number of reportsOneOne per party, plus a discussion between experts if the court directs one
Total cost to the disputeLower, because the records are reviewed onceHigher, because the same material is analysed twice and the differences then have to be narrowed
Cost to you individuallyUsually a share, subject to the court's directionsYour own expert's fee in full, plus costs risk on the outcome
Liability for the feeUnder rule 35.8(5), the relevant parties are jointly and severally liable unless the court directs otherwiseThe instructing party is liable to its own expert
Control of the instructionShared. Any relevant party may instruct, copying the othersYours, within the limits of the expert's duty to the court
Where it usually fitsFamily proceedings, lower value matters, and issues where the range of respectable opinion is narrowHigher value disputes and issues where valuation methodology or professional judgment is genuinely contested
Communication with the expertCopied to all relevant partiesDirect, subject to disclosure of the substance of instructions under rule 35.10(3)

The trade off, stated plainly

A single joint expert is cheaper and, in most matters, sufficient. It stops being sufficient where the issue turns on a methodological choice on which competent professionals genuinely differ, because a single report presents one such choice as the answer.

The honest test is whether you would be arguing about the method or the arithmetic. Arithmetic does not need two experts. Method sometimes does, and where the sum in dispute is large enough, the additional cost can be rational.

Controlling the cost of a joint instruction

  • Agree the questions jointly before instructing, so the expert is not reconciling two different briefs.
  • Ask the court to limit the amount payable under rule 35.4(4) where the fee is disproportionate to the issue.
  • Use rule 35.6 written questions properly. They are for clarification, and using them as cross-examination in writing generates fees on both sides.
  • Establish disclosure before the expert starts, not while they are working.

Rule 35.10(3) requires an expert's report to state the substance of all material instructions, written or oral, on which it was written. Rule 35.10(4) provides that those instructions are not privileged against disclosure. That applies to party appointed experts as much as to joint ones.

Get forensic accounting quotes

Two minutes to set out the instruction; forensic accountants respond directly with their fee basis and a stage estimate.

The matter

What is the instruction about?

  • No charge to you for the introduction
  • Your details go only to the practices that respond
  • Takes about two minutes

Questions, answered directly

What is a single joint expert?

CPR rule 35.2(2) defines a single joint expert as one instructed to prepare a report for the court on behalf of two or more of the parties to the proceedings. Rule 35.7 lets the court direct that one gives evidence on an issue, and select the expert if the parties cannot agree who.

Who pays a single joint expert's fees?

CPR rule 35.8(5): unless the court otherwise directs, the relevant parties are jointly and severally liable for the expert's fees and expenses. The court may also give directions about payment under rule 35.8(3). Under rule 35.8(4) it may limit the amount payable and direct that it be paid into court before the expert is instructed.

Is a party appointed expert worth the extra cost?

It depends on whether the dispute is about method or figures. Where competent professionals would genuinely differ on the valuation approach, a second expert can be justified if the sum in dispute supports it. Where the issue is the arithmetic or the completeness of the records, a single joint expert usually resolves it at a fraction of the cost.

Sources

This site's own datasets, every figure quoted from its source and dated:

  • The Expert Fee Caps carries 15 published figures read from 3 sources' own pages; the 5 published figures given without a breakdown run from 40 to 132.48 GBP, read 8 November 2026.
  • The Matrimonial Expert Instruction Rules carries 10 published figures read from 2 sources' own pages, from 2 to 35 day, read 7 November 2026.
  • For hourly, the median published figure in the UK Forensic Accounting Fee Index is 150 GBP across 3 figures from the sources' own pages (range 100 to 200 GBP), read 11 November 2026.
  1. justice.gov.uk, Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 (experts and assessors)
  2. justice.gov.uk, Practice Direction 35 (experts and assessors)
  3. justice.gov.uk, Family Procedure Rules Part 25 (experts in family proceedings)

An estimate for your matter, not a rate from an article.

Two minutes to set out the instruction; forensic accountants respond directly with their fee basis and a stage estimate.

Get forensic accounting quotes