Guide

CPR 35.4: expert evidence permission and cost estimates

Updated

The rules that govern expert evidence are also, in practice, cost control rules. Reading them before instructing tends to save more than negotiating the rate afterwards.

Get forensic accounting quotes Two minutes to set out the instruction; forensic accountants respond directly with their fee basis and a stage estimate.

CPR 35.4: expert evidence is permitted, not assumed

CPR rule 35.1 restricts expert evidence to that which is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings. Rule 35.4(1) provides that no party may call an expert or put in evidence an expert's report without the court's permission.

Rule 35.4(2) requires a party applying for permission to provide:

  • an estimate of the costs of the proposed expert evidence;
  • the field in which it is required;
  • the issues it will address;
  • where practicable, the name of the proposed expert.

Permission, if granted, is only in relation to that expert or that field (justice.gov.uk).

What that means when you take a quote

  • The estimate has a job to do. It is not simply a commercial indication: it goes before the court and informs whether permission is granted at all.
  • Scope is defined at the permission stage. The issues the expert evidence will address are identified then, which is another reason to frame the questions carefully before instructing.
  • Proportionality is live. Rule 35.1 exists to stop expert evidence that the dispute does not justify, so an estimate that is large relative to the sum at stake is a problem before it is an expense.
  • On the small claims and fast tracks, rule 35.4(3A) provides that permission for expert evidence will normally be given for only one expert on a particular issue.

What the report itself must contain

Rule 35.10(1) requires an expert's report to comply with Practice Direction 35 (justice.gov.uk). Rule 35.10(2) requires a closing statement that the expert understands and has complied with their duty to the court.

Rule 35.10(3) requires the report to state the substance of all material instructions, written or oral, on which it was written. Rule 35.10(4) provides that those instructions are not privileged against disclosure. A report that misses these requirements may have to be revised, which is a cost with no benefit.

The stages after the report

Written questions, rule 35.6
A party may put written questions to an expert about their report, for the purpose of clarification unless the court gives permission or the other party agrees otherwise.
Discussions between experts, rule 35.12
The court may direct a discussion between experts to identify and discuss the expert issues and, where possible, reach an agreed opinion, and may direct that they prepare a statement setting out what is agreed and what is not with reasons.
Use of a disclosed report, rule 35.11
Where a party has disclosed an expert's report, any party may use it as evidence at trial. That is worth understanding before commissioning a report you may not like.
The expert's own route to the court, rule 35.14
Experts may file written requests for directions to assist them in carrying out their functions, subject to the notice periods in that rule.

Part 35 governs civil proceedings. Expert evidence in family proceedings is governed by Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules, which similarly requires the court's permission and controls the cost of expert evidence. This page is general information about the rules, not legal advice on your case.

Get forensic accounting quotes

Two minutes to set out the instruction; forensic accountants respond directly with their fee basis and a stage estimate.

The matter

What is the instruction about?

  • No charge to you for the introduction
  • Your details go only to the practices that respond
  • Takes about two minutes

Questions, answered directly

Do I need the court's permission to rely on a forensic accountant's report?

In civil proceedings, yes. CPR rule 35.4(1) provides that no party may call an expert or put in evidence an expert's report without the court's permission. Rule 35.1 restricts expert evidence to what is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings. Family proceedings have an equivalent permission requirement under Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules.

What does CPR 35.4(2) require?

An estimate of the costs of the proposed expert evidence. You must also identify its field, the issues it will address and, where practicable, the name of the proposed expert. Permission, if granted, is only in relation to that expert or that field. So the estimate a forensic accountant gives you is the figure the court reads.

What must an expert's report contain?

It must comply with Practice Direction 35 and end with a statement that the expert understands and has complied with their duty to the court. It must state the substance of all material instructions, written or oral. Those are not privileged against disclosure, though questioning on them needs reasonable grounds to think the statement inaccurate or incomplete.

Can I commission a report and then not use it?

You can obtain advice without disclosing it, but be careful about the sequence. CPR rule 35.11 provides that where a party has disclosed an expert's report, any party may use that report as evidence at the trial. That is one reason experienced solicitors often begin with a preliminary view rather than a full report.

Sources

This site's own datasets, every figure quoted from its source and dated:

  • The Expert Fee Caps carries 15 published figures read from 3 sources' own pages; the 5 published figures given without a breakdown run from 40 to 132.48 GBP, read 8 November 2026.
  • The Matrimonial Expert Instruction Rules carries 10 published figures read from 2 sources' own pages, from 2 to 35 day, read 7 November 2026.
  • For hourly, the median published figure in the UK Forensic Accounting Fee Index is 150 GBP across 3 figures from the sources' own pages (range 100 to 200 GBP), read 11 November 2026.
  1. justice.gov.uk, Civil Procedure Rules Part 35 (experts and assessors)
  2. justice.gov.uk, Practice Direction 35 (experts and assessors)
  3. justice.gov.uk, Family Procedure Rules Part 25 (experts in family proceedings)

An estimate for your matter, not a rate from an article.

Two minutes to set out the instruction; forensic accountants respond directly with their fee basis and a stage estimate.

Get forensic accounting quotes